How to Tell if Mattress is Too Soft

There are several reasons why you may need to determine if your mattress is too soft, and they can include both comfort and health concerns. Firstly, a mattress that is too soft may not provide enough support for your body while you sleep. This can result in back or neck pain as well as muscle stiffness in the morning.

How to Tell if Mattress is Too Soft

There are several advantages to being able to tell if a mattress is too soft. One of the biggest advantages is that you will be able to choose the right level of support for your body and sleeping preferences.

A mattress that is too soft can cause discomfort, decreased quality of sleep, and even physical pain in some cases. In this blog post, You will learn in detail how to tell if mattress is too soft.

Step-by-step Instructions for How to Tell if Mattress is Too Soft

Step 1: Inspect  the Mattress

When trying to determine if your mattress is too soft, the first step is to inspect it. Look for any visible sagging or lumps in the surface of the mattress. These can indicate that your mattress has lost its firmness and may be too soft.

Step 2: Check Your Sleeping Position

Your sleeping position can also play a crucial role in determining if your mattress is too soft. If you are a back sleeper, you may find that your spine sinks into the mattress too much, causing discomfort and potential back pain. Side sleepers may also notice increased pressure on their hips and shoulders from sinking too far into the mattress.

Step 3: Consider Your Body Weight

A Soft Mattress Does Not Provide Enough

Another factor to consider is your body weight. Heavier individuals may find that a soft mattress does not provide enough support and can lead to discomfort or even pain. On the other hand, lighter individuals may find that a soft mattress is more comfortable and supportive.

If you share your bed with a partner, their sleeping position and body weight should also be taken into consideration. If they are significantly different from you, it may be causing uneven pressure on the mattress, making it feel too soft for one or both of you.

Step 4: Assess Your Comfort Level

Determining if Your Mattress is Too Soft

Ultimately, your comfort level is the most important factor in determining if your mattress is too soft. If you wake up feeling achy and uncomfortable, or if you find yourself tossing and turning throughout the night, it may be a sign that your mattress is too soft for your needs.

The “Goldilocks Test” involves lying on your mattress and checking if it feels just right. If you sink in too far or feel like you’re sleeping on a cloud, then your mattress may be too soft. If you feel like you’re lying on a hard surface, then your mattress may be too firm.

Step 5: Consider Your Temperature

A soft mattress can also affect your body temperature while sleeping. Memory foam and other types of soft mattresses tend to retain heat, making you feel uncomfortably warm throughout the night. If you find yourself waking up sweating, it could be a sign that your mattress is too soft and not allowing enough air circulation.

Pain or discomfort in your neck, back, hips, or shoulders can also be a sign that your mattress is too soft. These areas may not be properly supported by a softer mattress, causing strain and discomfort. If these issues persist even after changing sleeping positions, it may be time to consider a firmer mattress.

Step 6: Evaluate the Age of Your Mattress

Mattresses Tend to Lose Their Firmness

Over time, mattresses tend to lose their firmness and support. If your mattress is older than 7 years, it may be time for a replacement. This could also be the cause of any discomfort or feeling of softness in your current mattress.

If you are still unsure if your mattress is too soft after following these steps, it may be helpful to consult a professional. A sleep expert or chiropractor can provide insight and advice on the best type of mattress for your specific needs and preferences.

By following these step-by-step instructions, you can determine if your mattress is too soft and make an informed decision on whether it’s time for a new one. Remember, the right mattress should provide proper support and comfort for a restful night’s sleep.

Safety Tips for How to Tell if Mattress is Too Soft

  1. Avoid jumping or bouncing on the mattress, as this can damage the internal structure and cause it to become softer over time.
  2. Check the firmness level of your mattress before purchasing by pressing down on various areas with your hand. If there is excessive give or sinking, the mattress may be too soft for your needs.
  3. Consider your body weight and sleeping position when choosing a mattress. Heavier individuals may require a firmer mattress for proper support and alignment.
  4. Rotate your mattress regularly (every 3-6 months) to prevent uneven wear and maintain its firmness level.
  5. Use a mattress protector to protect against spills, stains, and other damage that can affect the firmness of your mattress.
  6. Avoid placing your mattress directly on the floor, as this can trap moisture and accelerate wear, causing it to become softer.
  7. If you have chronic back pain or other health issues, consult with a doctor or physical therapist for recommendations on the best mattress firmness for your specific needs.
Best Mattress Firmness for Your Specific Needs

By following these safety tips, you can ensure that your mattress remains at the optimal firmness level for a comfortable and supportive sleep. Additionally, it is important to regularly assess the firmness of your mattress and make adjustments as needed to maintain its quality and durability.

Signs of a Too-soft Mattress

1. Poor Quality Sleep

One of the biggest signs that your mattress is too soft is if you are waking up feeling tired and achy. A good quality mattress should provide support for your body, allowing you to get a restful night’s sleep.

However, if your mattress is too soft, it may not be able to properly support your body, causing discomfort and disrupting your sleep. This can lead to feeling groggy and fatigued throughout the day, as well as potential long-term health issues.

2. Back and Joint Pain

Another telltale sign of a too-soft mattress is experiencing back and joint pain upon waking up. Your mattress should provide proper spinal alignment and support for your body while you sleep.

However, a soft mattress may cause your spine to sink into the bed, leading to an unnatural curvature and putting strain on your back and joints. Over time, this can lead to chronic pain and discomfort.

3. Sagging or Indentations

A good quality mattress should be able to maintain its shape and support over time. However, if you notice sagging or indentations in your mattress, it could be a sign that it is too soft and not providing enough support. This can also lead to uncomfortable pressure points on your body, which can cause pain and disrupt your sleep.

4. Difficulty Getting In and Out of Bed

Struggling to Get in and Out of Bed

If you find yourself struggling to get in and out of bed, it may be due to a too-soft mattress. A soft mattress can sink under your weight, making it difficult to move and causing strain on your muscles. This can be especially problematic for older adults or those with mobility issues.

5. Allergy Symptoms

A too-soft mattress can also contribute to allergy symptoms such as sneezing, watery eyes, and congestion. Dust mites tend to thrive in softer mattresses, as they can easily burrow into the material. This can cause irritation for those with allergies and lead to poor sleep quality.

To prevent these issues, it is important to choose a mattress that provides the right level of support for your body. This may vary depending on your weight, sleeping position, and personal preferences. It is also recommended to replace your mattress every 7-10 years to ensure optimal comfort and support.

Solutions for Addressing a Too-soft Mattress

1. Use a Mattress Topper

If your mattress is too soft, but still in good condition, a simple solution is to use a mattress topper. This extra layer can provide additional support and help alleviate any discomfort caused by a too-soft mattress.

2. Replace the Foundation

Your Bed Frame or Box Spring

Sometimes the issue may not be with the mattress itself, but with the foundation it is placed on. If your bed frame or box spring is not providing enough support, it can cause a mattress to feel softer than intended. Consider replacing the foundation with a sturdier option.

3. Adjust Sleeping Position

Your sleeping position can also play a role in how a mattress feels. For example, side sleepers may prefer a softer mattress for better pressure relief, while back and stomach sleepers may need a firmer mattress for proper support. Experiment with different sleeping positions to find what works best for you.

4. Try Different Mattress Materials

Different types of mattresses can have varying levels of firmness and support. Memory foam or latex mattresses tend to be softer, while innerspring or hybrid mattresses offer more support. Consider trying out different materials to find the right balance for your needs.

5. Use Pillows for Support

In addition to a mattress, your pillows can also impact how well-supported you are while sleeping. Using pillows strategically under your head, neck, and knees can help alleviate strain on your body and provide better alignment.

6. Consult with a Chiropractor

If you are experiencing persistent pain and discomfort from a too-soft mattress, it may be beneficial to consult with a chiropractor. They can provide personalized recommendations for addressing your specific issues and help alleviate any pain or tension.

7. Invest in a New Mattress

If all else fails, it may be time to invest in a new mattress that is better suited for your needs. Take the time to research and try out different options before making a purchase, as a good quality mattress is an investment in your overall health and well-being. Remember to also regularly rotate and flip your new mattress to maintain its shape and support for years to come.

DIY Fixes for Temporary Relief

1. Firm Up the Mattress

Your Mattress is Feeling Too Soft

If your mattress is feeling too soft, you can try placing a piece of plywood or cardboard between the mattress and foundation to create a firmer surface. This will only provide temporary relief, but it can help make your mattress feel more supportive.

2. Use Towels or Blankets for Extra Padding

Another temporary fix is to place towels or blankets on top of the mattress to add extra padding and support. This can help alleviate pressure points and prevent sinking into the mattress.

3. Adjust the Temperature

Believe it or not, temperature can also impact how a mattress feels. A too-soft mattress may feel even softer in warmer temperatures, so try adjusting the thermostat or using cooling sheets to create a firmer sensation.

4. Change Your Sheets

Similar to using towels or blankets, changing your sheets to a thicker material can create a firmer sleeping surface. Flannel or jersey knit sheets, for example, can add extra padding and make a soft mattress feel more supportive.

5. Use a Body Pillow

If you have issues with spinal alignment on a too-soft mattress, using a body pillow can help. Place it between your legs or under your knees to provide better support and alleviate any discomfort.

6. Try Different Sleep Positions

Experimenting with different sleep positions, such as sleeping on your back instead of your side, can also provide temporary relief from a too-soft mattress. This can help distribute weight more evenly and prevent excessive sinking.

7. Use a Mattress Pad

Similar to a Mattress Topper

Similar to a mattress topper, a mattress pad can provide extra cushioning and support on top of your existing mattress. Look for one specifically designed for firmness or support to get the best results.

Whether you are experiencing discomfort from a too-soft mattress or looking to prevent future issues, it is important to understand the signs and solutions for addressing this common issue. Remember to prioritize your comfort and support when selecting a mattress, and don’t be afraid to experiment with different strategies for temporary relief.

What Are Some Long-term Solutions for a Too-soft Mattress?

There are several long-term solutions for a too-soft mattress that you can consider. One option is to invest in a mattress topper. A mattress topper is an extra layer of cushioning that sits on top of your existing mattress, providing additional support and comfort.

This can help alleviate some of the sinking feeling caused by a too-soft mattress. Another solution is to rotate and flip your mattress regularly. This can help distribute the weight and wear of the mattress more evenly, preventing it from becoming too soft in certain areas.

If you are looking for a more permanent solution, consider replacing your mattress with a firmer one. There are many different types of mattresses available on the market, so be sure to do some research and try out different options to find the perfect level of firmness for your needs.

Proper maintenance and care are also important when it comes to maintaining the firmness of your mattress. Making sure to regularly clean and rotate your mattress, as well as using a sturdy bed frame, can go a long way in preserving the firmness of your mattress over time.

What Are Some Potential Reasons for a Mattress Becoming Too Soft Over Time?

There are a few possible reasons for a mattress becoming too soft over time. Here are some of the most common factors to consider:

  • Wear and Tear: Over time, the materials used in mattresses can break down due to regular use. This is especially true for cheaper or lower quality mattresses that may have less durable components.
  • Body Heat: Did you know that our body heat can actually affect the firmness of a mattress? As we sleep, our bodies release heat which can cause some mattresses to soften and lose their original level of support.
  • Moisture: If you live in a humid environment or tend to sweat a lot while sleeping, this could also contribute to a mattress becoming too soft. Excess moisture can seep into the materials and cause them to break down, resulting in a less supportive mattress.
  • Improper Cleaning: Regularly cleaning your mattress is important for maintaining its structure and preventing buildup of dust, dirt, and allergens. However, using too much moisture or harsh chemicals during the cleaning process can also damage the materials and lead to a softer mattress.
  • Age: Just like any other product, mattresses also have a lifespan. Depending on the quality and type of materials used, a mattress can start to lose its firmness after 5-10 years.
  • Weight: The weight of the person or people sleeping on the mattress can also play a role in how quickly it becomes too soft. Heavier individuals may cause more strain and wear on the materials, leading to a faster deterioration of the firmness.

To prevent your mattress from becoming too soft, it’s important to invest in a high-quality mattress and regularly rotate or flip it as recommended by the manufacturer. Additionally, using a mattress protector can help maintain its structure and prevent moisture buildup.

Are There Any Tips for Maintaining the Firmness of a Mattress Over Time?

There are a few tips you can follow to maintain the firmness of your mattress over time. These include:

1. Rotate and Flip Your Mattress

Your Mattress is by Regularly Rotating and Flipping

One of the most effective ways to maintain the firmness of your mattress is by regularly rotating and flipping it. This will help distribute your body weight evenly, preventing one side from getting too compressed or worn out. Most mattresses should be rotated and flipped every 3-6 months, but always check the manufacturer’s guidelines for specific recommendations.

2. Use a Mattress Topper

Another way to protect the firmness of your mattress is by using a mattress topper. This extra layer of padding can help absorb body weight and pressure, reducing strain on your mattress. It also acts as a barrier between your body and the mattress, preventing sweat and oils from seeping into the material.

3. Avoid Sitting on the Edge of Your Mattress

When sitting on your bed, try to avoid sitting directly on the edge of your mattress. This can cause uneven compression in that area, leading to a loss of firmness over time. Instead, sit closer towards the center of the bed or use a chair for support.

4. Keep Your Mattress Clean

Regularly cleaning your mattress can also help maintain its firmness. This includes vacuuming it to remove any dust, dead skin cells, and other debris that can build up over time. You should also spot clean any spills or stains as soon as possible to prevent them from setting in and potentially damaging the material of your mattress.

5. Consider Temperature and Humidity

The temperature and humidity levels in your bedroom can also impact the firmness of your mattress. High heat and humidity can cause materials like foam to soften, while colder temperatures can make them feel firmer. It’s important to keep your room at a comfortable temperature and use a dehumidifier if necessary to prevent your mattress from losing its firmness.

6. Don’t Jump on Your Mattress

While it may be tempting, try to avoid jumping on your mattress as this can cause damage and affect its firmness over time. The repeated impact of jumping can compress the materials and weaken the overall structure of the mattress.

Maintain the Firmness of Your Mattress

By following these tips, you can help maintain the firmness of your mattress and extend its lifespan. Remember to also regularly check for any signs of wear and tear, and consider replacing your mattress if it’s no longer providing the necessary support for a good night’s sleep.


The main  disadvantage of determining if a mattress is too soft is that there isn’t a single standard way to measure and define “softness”. Softness can be subjective and vary from person to person, depending on their preference. A mattress that feels too soft for one person might feel just right for another.

In conclusion,  choosing the right mattress is crucial for getting a good night’s sleep and ensuring proper spinal alignment. A mattress that is too soft can lead to discomfort, pain, and even long-term health issues.

I hope this article has been beneficial for learning how to tell if mattress is too soft. Make Sure the precautionary measures are followed chronologically.

Photo of author

Adrian Green

Adrian is a woodworking hobbyist and has loved Woodworking since he was 10 years old. Back then in childhood, his father used to have a furniture shop. He used to help his dad and learned a lot from him about how to fix woodworking furniture, basic carpentry knowledge and also about how to work hard and take care of business. He enjoys woodworking as a hobby. He loves the feeling of creating something with his own hands, and the satisfaction that comes from seeing his finished products used by others.

Leave a Comment